Cheese of the future: are consumers open to alternatives?

Companies and institutes are currently working on biotechnological processes for the production of dairy products without the use of cows. In so-called precision fermentation, egg and milk proteins are produced with the help of bacteria, yeasts or other fungi. This can result in alternatives to milk or cheese that have a familiar flavour and texture but will consumers accept such products?

Researchers at the University of Göttingen in Germany have found that a large proportion of German consumers are willing to try and buy cheese produced in this way. The results of the study have been published in the international journal Future Foods.

The study, which was conducted in collaboration with LI Food — Landesinitiative Ernährungswirtschaft Niedersachsen and the German Institute of Food Technologies (DIL), is based on a representative online survey with around 2000 participants.

The researchers analysed how various aspects of information affect the acceptance of cheese produced in this way. They analysed the potential opportunities and risks of the technology, including its relation to sustainability, impact on agriculture and product quality.

In general, the research found that information has only a minor influence on whether consumers would try or buy cheese from precision fermentation. Only the reference to the technological genetic modification of the microorganisms required for the production process leads to a slightly significantly lower willingness to try the product.

Respondents were also confronted with the potential advantages and disadvantages of this technology. It was found that emphasising the consistently high quality of the products and advantages in terms of the environment and animal welfare in particular increased the willingness to try such cheese. The situation is different when consumers are informed about possible risks, for example, that farmers could lose their source of income due to the new technology or that large companies could exert too much power on the market. These aspects reduced the willingness to buy and pay for such cheese the most.

“Our study shows that consumers in Germany are open to cheese from precision fermentation if they are informed about the benefits and high quality of the product. However, it is important to design the communication carefully to address concerns about the impact on traditional agriculture,” said first author Dr Sarah Kühl, Chair for Marketing for Food and Agricultural Products at the University of Göttingen.

Corresponding products are already on the market in the US; authorisation in Germany and the European Union is still pending. The technology as such is not new — it is already used in the production of medicines such as insulin.

Image credit: iStock.com/Vanessa Nunes